WS-SM-18 | Meetings

Workshop on Spatial Management

Location:

Cambridge, UK

Meeting Start Date/Time:

Monday, 2 July 2018

Meeting End Date/Time:

Friday, 6 July 2018

Submissions Due

Monday, 18 June 2018 - 00:00 Australia/Hobart (Working Group Paper)

Please note that meeting-specific information is now available.

Need help? Check out our support forum for tips and tricks and videos.

Before you arrive: Familiarise yourself with the functionality of the meeting server.

Meeting Report:

e-sc-xxxvii-a7.pdf (510.61 KB)

Meeting Documents

Documents

Document Number	Title	Agenda Item(s)
SC-CAMLR-XXXVII/01 More Info	Report of the Co-conveners of the CCAMLR Workshop for the Development of a Dissostichus mawsoni Population Hypothesis for Area 48 (19 to 21 February 2018, Berlin, Germany) Workshop Co-conveners (C. Darby (UK) and C. Jones (USA)) Submitted By: Dr Chris Darby Approved By: Dr Chris Darby Request Meeting Document	2
WG-SAM-18/21 More Info	Guidelines for fisheries-directed research addressing the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area Research and Monitoring Plan S. Parker and A. Dunn Abstract: Implementation of the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area (CM 91-05) and the associated Research and Monitoring Plan (SC-CAMLR XXXVI-20) requires multidisciplinary research efforts by Members. Some of the research required will necessarily be implemented through CCAMLR approved fisheries research programmes proposed under CM 24‑01. Although considerable fisheries research is already underway Read More Submitted By: Mr Alistair Dunn Approved By: Mr Alistair Dunn Request Meeting Document	6.3
WG-SAM-18/33 Rev. 1 More Info	Annex to WS-DmPH-18 report: Towards the development of a stock hypothesis for Antarctic toothfish (Dissostichus mawsoni) in Area 48 M. Söffker, A. Riley, M. Belchier, K. Teschke, H. Pehlke, S. Somhlaba, J. Graham, T. Namba, C.D. van der Lingen, T. Okuda, C. Darby, O.T. Albert, O.A. Bergstad, P. Brtnik, J. Caccavo, A. Capurro, C. Dorey, L. Ghigliotti, S. Hain, C. Jones, S. Kasatkina, M. La Mesa, D. Marichev, E. Molloy, C. Papetti, L. Pshenichnov, K. Reid, M.M. Santos and D. Welsford Abstract: Annex paper to the WS-DmpH-18 meeting report (part 2 of 2) Submitted By: Dr Marta Söffker (European Union) Approved By: Dr Chris Darby Request Meeting Document	3.2
WS-DmPH-18/01 More Info	Materials on biodiversity in Subareas 48.6 and 48.5 in the frame of the Weddell Sea MPA Delegation of the Russian Federation Abstract: It is shown that the proposals for the establishment of an MPA in the Weddell Sea should be complemented by information on the commercial potential and future rational use for dominant fish species and krill in Subareas 48.5 and 48.6. Submitted By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Approved By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Request Meeting Document	3.2
WS-DmPH-18/02 More Info	Оn seasonal and interannual dynamics of ice conditions in the Weddell Sea and its relation to the WSMPA planning Delegation of the Russian Federation Abstract: The proposed boundaries of the Weddell Sea MPA (WSMPA) include the significant area of 1.3 million km². It is shown that the WSMPA boundaries should be revised in compliance with sea-ice conditions for vessel navigation being a fundamental factor for the successful completion of assigned research tasks in designated areas. Submitted By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Approved By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Request Meeting Document	3.2
WS-SM-18/01 More Info	Baseline data layers used for spatial planning, monitoring and research in relation to the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area M. Pinkerton and B. Sharp Abstract: This paper provides data layers relevant to establishing the baseline for the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area (MPA). We provide data used to investigate environmental and ecological spatial patterns as part of the design and evaluation process for the Ross Sea region MPA, including spatial maps and information on key Ross Sea ecosystem processes, and data layers used to determine the Read More Submitted By: Mr Alistair Dunn Approved By: Mr Alistair Dunn Request Meeting Document	4.2
WS-SM-18/02 More Info	Candidate baseline data for ecosystem indicators in the Ross Sea region A. Dahood and G.M. Watters Abstract: The research and management plan for the Ross Sea region MPA is currently under development. That plan will identify key research questions that aid in assessing the MPA’s efficacy in achieving its objectives. It may be helpful to have an agreed set of baseline data for key species which indicate the current status of marine ecosystems in the Ross Sea region. These data could then be used as Read More Submitted By: Dr George Watters Approved By: Dr George Watters Request Meeting Document	4.2
WS-SM-18/03 More Info	Summary of New Zealand research projects relevant to the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area M. Pinkerton and J. Scarrow Abstract: This paper provides a summary of research projects and activities led by New Zealand researchers that are relevant to spatial planning, monitoring and research in relation to the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area. The inventory includes: (1) research to establish “baseline” environmental and ecological conditions in the Ross Sea region; (2) “process-based” research to understand Read More Submitted By: Mr Alistair Dunn Approved By: Mr Alistair Dunn Request Meeting Document	4.2
WS-SM-18/04 More Info	Developing the risk assessment framework for the Antarctic krill fishery in Area 48 P. Trathan, V. Warwick-Evans, E. Young, S. Thorpe, E. Murphy, N. Kelly, S. Kawaguchi and D. Welsford Abstract: Recognising that CM 51-07 is scheduled to lapse at the end of the 2020/2021 fishing season, we outline a plan of work to engage with the CCAMLR community to move towards refining the krill risk assessment framework. WG-EMM has previously offered advice about how the risk assessment might be improved for the future. We therefore indicate key areas for community engagement to help develop the Read More Submitted By: Dr Phil Trathan Approved By: Ms Kylie Bamford (United Kingdom) Request Meeting Document	4.1
WS-SM-18/05 More Info	An experimental approach for the Antarctic krill fishery: advancing management and conservation through the use of Krill Reference Areas and Krill Fishing Areas P.N Trathan and O.R. Godø Abstract: We review reasons why the fishery for Antarctic krill is challenging to manage and consider ways in which management could be improved, whilst responsible and precautionary harvesting continues. We propose an experimental framework to help improve the scientific basis for management. This framework will enhance conservation, and increase ecological understanding by using an experimental Read More Submitted By: Dr Phil Trathan Approved By: Ms Kylie Bamford (United Kingdom) Request Meeting Document	2, 3.1, 4.1
WS-SM-18/06 More Info	Hierarchical monitoring plans to determine patterns of change in the Antarctic Marine Ecosystem P. Trathan Abstract: In this paper we drawn comparison between the existing CCAMLR Ecosystem Monitoring Programme (CEMP) and plans to develop Research and Monitoring Plans for Marine Protected Areas. We recall the outcomes of the CEMP Review in 2003, and as a result highlight the intensity of monitoring required to detect change and to ascribe cause. We therefore propose that CCAMLR build even stronger links with Read More Submitted By: Dr Phil Trathan Approved By: Ms Kylie Bamford (United Kingdom) Request Meeting Document	4.1
WS-SM-18/07 More Info	Predator trophic hotspots in the Indian sector of the subantarctic Southern Ocean: how do they overlap with marine protected areas? M. O’Toole, S. Sergi, A. Baudena, C. Cotté, C. Bost, C. Guinet, H. Weimerskirch, M.A. Hindell, P. Koubbi and F. d’Ovidio Abstract: The Indian sector of the subantarctic region hosts large populations of top predators which are listed at various level of vulnerability by the IUCN and which are monitored by several bio-logging programs since the late 1980s. Here we analyze more than 800 individuals from seven different pelagic species of albatross, penguins and pinnipeds. Merging our analysis with previous results, we find Read More Submitted By: Professor Philippe Koubbi Approved By: Professor Philippe Koubbi Request Meeting Document	3.3
WS-SM-18/08 More Info	Informing and seeking advice from WS-SM 2018 about the revisions of the WSMPA proposal S. Hain, K. Teschke, H. Pehlke and T. Brey Abstract: Following the submission of a first draft Conservation Measure for establishing a MPA in the Weddell Sea (WSMPA) to CCAMLR 2016, Germany has carried out further work on the WSMPA proposal and will submit a revised CM proposal to CCAMLR 2018. This document informs The Workshop on Spatial Management (WS-SM-2018) about the following revisions carried out to the WSMPA proposal which would Read More Submitted By: Ms Patricia Brtnik Approved By: Professor Thomas Brey (Germany) Request Meeting Document	3.2
WS-SM-18/09 More Info	Comments on the development of a Dissostichus mawsoni Population Hypothesis for Area 48. Proposals on the WS-SM-18 advice to the to the Scientific Committee and its Working Group Delegation of the Russian Federation Abstract: Taking into account the results of the WS-DmPH workshop (Berlin, 2018), proposals are being considered to obtain actual adequate data for the development of a hypothesis on the Dissostichus mawsoni life history and to facilitate the assessment of its stock in Area 48. Submitted By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Approved By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Request Meeting Document	3.2, 6, 8
WS-SM-18/10 More Info	Comments on the use of MPA for spatial management in the CCAMLR area Delegation of the Russian Federation Abstract: The use of MPAs for spatial management in the Convention Area requires, above all, clarity regarding the requirements for the available scientific evidence and information to designate MPAs, including its rationale, planning and functioning. The corresponding proposals are discussed in this paper. Submitted By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Approved By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Request Meeting Document	2, 3.2, 4.1
WS-SM-18/11 More Info	Peculiarities of spatial-temporal variability of oceanological conditions in the Weddell Sea region in the context of the development of a stock hypothesis for Antarctic toothfish (Dissostichus mawsoni) in Area 48 V. Shnar and S. Kasatkina Abstract: A significant spatial-temporal variability of the oceanological environmental conditions influencing the formation of biological productivity zone in Subareas 48.5 and 48.6 is revealed. Analysis of available information for the development of the stock hypothesis for Antarctic toothfish stock in Area 48 requires consideration of environmental variability, especially with the fragmentary Read More Submitted By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Approved By: Dr Svetlana Kasatkina (Russian Federation) Request Meeting Document	3.2
WS-SM-18/12 Rev. 1 More Info	Progress towards a representative network of Southern Ocean protected areas C. Brooks, S. Chown, L. Douglass and B. Raymond Abstract: Global threats to ocean biodiversity have generated a worldwide movement to take actions towards improved conservation and management. Several international targets have recommended the adoption of marine protected areas (MPAs) in national and international waters. While establishing MPAs in international waters has proven to be challenging in most of the world, national governments and the Read More Submitted By: Dr George Watters Approved By: Dr George Watters Request Meeting Document	2
WS-SM-18/13 More Info	Scientific background document in support of the development of a CCAMLR MPA in the Weddell Sea (Antarctica) – Version 2018 – Reflection on the recommendations by WG-EMM-17 and SC-CAMLR-XXXVI K. Teschke, H. Pehlke and T. Brey Abstract: The CAMLR Scientific Committee in 2017 reviewed the scientific background document SC-CAMLR- XXXVI/BG/28. Germany was asked to carry out further work, in particular as regards the issues and questions raised at WG-EMM-17 and SC-CAMLR-XXXVI with respect to the WSMPA proposal (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, Annex 6, §§ 5.1-5.14). Chapter 1 reflects on the recommendations concerning the Read More Submitted By: Dr Katharina Teschke Approved By: Professor Thomas Brey (Germany) Request Meeting Document	3.2
WS-SM-18/14 More Info	Are we there yet? Evaluating and reporting progress towards a Representative System of Marine Protected Area across the CAMLR Convention Area D.C. Welsford Abstract: In 2008, CCAMLR agreed that the establishment of a representative system of marine protected areas (RSMPA) by 2012 was a priority. This assessment shows that the Scientific Committee and Commission can be kept informed of progress towards this goal using a relatively short list of simple criteria that are based on robust ecological and experimental design principles, and the Commission’s Read More Submitted By: Dr Dirk Welsford (Australia) Approved By: Dr Dirk Welsford (Australia) Request Meeting Document	2
WS-SM-18/15 More Info	Research and Monitoring Plan for the South Orkney Islands Southern Shelf Marine Protected Area (MPA Planning Domain 1, Subarea 48.2) P.N. Trathan and S. Grant Abstract: This paper aims to advance the dialogue about the development of a revised RMP for the SOI SS MPA in order to further the harmonisation of CM 91-03 and CM 91-04, whilst recognising and aiming to contribute to the wider context of the MPA planning processes in Domain 1, and as appropriate, Domain 3. Submitted By: Dr Phil Trathan Approved By: Dr Chris Darby Request Meeting Document	4.2
WS-SM-18/16 More Info	Proposed initiative to contribute to Ross Sea region MPA research and monitoring activities using pop-up satellite tags and otolith chemistry on Dissostichus mawsoni C.D. Jones Abstract: An initiative to support research and monitoring of the Ross Sea Region Marine Protected Area (RSRMPA) through satellite tagging and otolith microchemistry of Antarctic toothfish (Dissosticus mawsoni) within the RSRMPA is proposed. The objectives of this initiative are twofold. The first is to deploy a total 20 pop-off satellite tags (PSAT) on juvenile toothfish within the General Read More Submitted By: Dr Christopher Jones (United States of America) Approved By: Dr George Watters Request Meeting Document	4.2
WS-SM-18/17 More Info	The identification of scientific reference areas in the wider context of MPA planning – report of the CCAMLR scholarship recipient A. Capurro, M.M. Santos, R. Cavanagh and S. Grant Abstract: Domain 1 faces changes to the climate and changes in the operation of the fishery, in which the recent D1MPA preliminary proposal is of particular importance. In this context, the identification of a comprehensive network of reference areas across environmental gradients can play a major role and have significant benefits in understanding change. Existing monitoring programmes and study sites Read More Submitted By: Ms Andrea Capurro Approved By: Dr Enrique Marschoff (Argentina) Request Meeting Document	3.1
WS-SM-18/18 More Info	Further information in relation to krill fisheries in the D1MPA process A. Capurro and M.M. Santos with contributions from the D1MPA Expert Group Abstract: The D1MPA planning process has been characterized as inclusive and transparent taking into account Members’ varying interests. In 2017 a D1MPA preliminary proposal was introduced to the Scientific Committee which scientific background was considered comprehensive and appropriate, and where further consideration of fishing activities were highlighted as needed to develop an agreed set of Read More Submitted By: Ms Andrea Capurro Approved By: Dr Enrique Marschoff (Argentina) Request Meeting Document	3.1
WS-SM-18/P01 More Info	Abundance and richness of key Antarctic seafloor fauna correlates with modelled food availability J. Jansen, N.A. Hill, P.K. Dunstan, J. McKinlay, M.D. Sumner, A.L. Post, M.P. Eléaume, L.K. Armand, J.P. Warncock, B.K. Galton-Fenzi and C.R. Johnson Abstract: Most seafloor communities at depths below the photosynthesis zone rely on food that sinks through the water column. However, the nature and strength of this pelagic–benthic coupling and its influence on the structure and diversity of seafloor communities is unclear, especially around Antarctica where ecological data are sparse. Here we show that the strength of pelagic–benthic coupling along Read More Submitted By: Dr Nicole Hill (Australia) Approved By: Dr Dirk Welsford (Australia) Publication: Nature Ecology & Evolution, 2 (2017): 71–80, doi: 10.1038/s41559-017-0392-3 Request Meeting Document	3, 4.1
WS-SM-18/P02 More Info	Model-based mapping of assemblages for ecology and conservation management: A case study of demersal fish on the Kerguelen Plateau N.A. Hill, S.D. Foster, G. Duhamel, D. Welsford, P. Koubbi and C.R. Johnson Abstract: Quantifying biological assemblages and their environment is a fundamental, yet statistically challenging task in conservation ecology. Here we use a recently-developed approach called Regions of Common Profile (RCP) to quantify and map the distribution of demersal fish assemblages in an ecologically significant region of the Southern Ocean to a) gain ecological and management insights and b) Read More Submitted By: Dr Nicole Hill (Australia) Approved By: Dr Dirk Welsford (Australia) Publication: Diversity Distrib., 23 (2017): 1216–1230 Request Meeting Document	3, 4.1
WS-SM-18/P03 More Info	What’s the catch? Profiling the risks and costs associated with marine protected areas and displaced fishing in the Scotia Sea E.S. Klein and G.M. Watters Abstract: A principal concern with implementing marine protected areas (MPAs) is the displacement of fishing effort from closed areas, which may result in new and unexpected consequences for both fisheries and the ecosystem. Understanding such outcomes is critical in the Southern Ocean, where MPAs are actively being discussed for achieving a range of protection and sustainable use objectives. Here, we Read More Submitted By: Dr George Watters Approved By: Dr George Watters Publication: PLos ONE (submitted) Request Meeting Document	3.1

0.037

Agenda

Expand All Annotations | Expand All Documents | Collapse All

1 Introduction

Annotations

In 2017, the Scientific Committee agreed to hold a Workshop on Spatial Management (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, paragraph 13.23) as part of its five-year work plan. It also noted a number of issues related to specific MPA planning processes that could be discussed further at the workshop.

The Scientific Committee’s five-year work plan (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI/BG/40) set out science topics under the theme of ‘Spatial management of impacts on the Antarctic ecosystem’, and highlighted two priority topics for the Workshop on Spatial Management:

Spatial planning data management
Implementation of the Ross Sea Region MPA Research and Monitoring Plan

The workshop terms of reference were developed intersessionally, based on the science topics and priorities in the five-year work plan, and were updated following feedback from Members (SC CIRC 18/18).

Submitted workshop papers, along with presentations and analyses conducted during the workshop, will form the basis for discussion and advice.

Documents

0.017

1.1 Opening of the meeting

Annotations

Welcome to participants and overview of facilities, Secretariat’s offices, computer support, internet access and social activities.

Documents

0.019

1.2 Adoption of the agenda and organisation of the meeting

Annotations

Amendments to, and adoption of, the meeting agenda, assignment of meeting papers to agenda items, appointment of rapporteurs and procedures for the preparation of the report and establishment of ad hoc subgroups if necessary.

Documents

0.029

2 Development of general principles for the use of spatial management tools in the CCAMLR area

Annotations

The Workshop will consider general principles, in pursuance of the objective and principles of the Convention, to make use of the full range of spatial management tools available to be implemented under CM 91-04 and other mechanisms. Where possible, the workshop will aim to identify common elements and approaches on issues including:

Achievement of the objectives of CM 91-04 across the Convention Area
Criteria and methods to scientifically interpret and measure the achievement of MPA objectives
Scientific background information and methodologies required for spatial management planning processes, including considerations of data availability.

Documents

SC-CAMLR-XXXVII/01	Report of the Co-conveners of the CCAMLR Workshop for the Development of a Dissostichus mawsoni Population Hypothesis for Area 48 (19 to 21 February 2018, Berlin, Germany) Workshop Co-conveners (C. Darby (UK) and C. Jones (USA))
WS-SM-18/05	An experimental approach for the Antarctic krill fishery: advancing management and conservation through the use of Krill Reference Areas and Krill Fishing Areas P.N Trathan and O.R. Godø
WS-SM-18/10	Comments on the use of MPA for spatial management in the CCAMLR area Delegation of the Russian Federation
WS-SM-18/12 Rev. 1	Progress towards a representative network of Southern Ocean protected areas C. Brooks, S. Chown, L. Douglass and B. Raymond
WS-SM-18/14	Are we there yet? Evaluating and reporting progress towards a Representative System of Marine Protected Area across the CAMLR Convention Area D.C. Welsford

0.384

3 Development of MPA proposals

Annotations

The workshop will review technical issues relating to the development of specific MPA proposals, including on available scientific data and methodological approaches. It will aim to provide advice in response to specific questions identified during SC-CAMLR-XXXVI.

Documents

WS-SM-18/P01	Abundance and richness of key Antarctic seafloor fauna correlates with modelled food availability J. Jansen, N.A. Hill, P.K. Dunstan, J. McKinlay, M.D. Sumner, A.L. Post, M.P. Eléaume, L.K. Armand, J.P. Warncock, B.K. Galton-Fenzi and C.R. Johnson
WS-SM-18/P02	Model-based mapping of assemblages for ecology and conservation management: A case study of demersal fish on the Kerguelen Plateau N.A. Hill, S.D. Foster, G. Duhamel, D. Welsford, P. Koubbi and C.R. Johnson

0.027

3.1 Planning Domain 1 (western Antarctic Peninsula and southern Scotia Sea)

Annotations

The workshop will review progress and updates on the development of a proposal for a system of MPAs in Planning Domain 1, including work progressed by the Domain 1 MPA Expert Group. This will include consideration of issues raised by WG-EMM (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, Annex 6, paragraphs 4.21 to 4.22) and the Scientific Committee (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, paragraphs 5.19 to 5.35).

Focus topics identified by the D1MPA Expert Group for its work include:

Climate change and reference areas for D1MPA;
Krill fishery management strategies and harmonisation with D1MPA;
Information on fisheries in the D1MPA planning process (e.g. cost layer, krill fishery displacement, toothfish research fishery).

Documents

WS-SM-18/05	An experimental approach for the Antarctic krill fishery: advancing management and conservation through the use of Krill Reference Areas and Krill Fishing Areas P.N Trathan and O.R. Godø
WS-SM-18/17	The identification of scientific reference areas in the wider context of MPA planning – report of the CCAMLR scholarship recipient A. Capurro, M.M. Santos, R. Cavanagh and S. Grant
WS-SM-18/18	Further information in relation to krill fisheries in the D1MPA process A. Capurro and M.M. Santos with contributions from the D1MPA Expert Group
WS-SM-18/P03	What’s the catch? Profiling the risks and costs associated with marine protected areas and displaced fishing in the Scotia Sea E.S. Klein and G.M. Watters

0.154

3.2 Planning Domains 3 and 4 (Weddell Sea)

Annotations

The workshop will review progress and updates on the proposed Weddell Sea MPA, including consideration of issues raised by WG-EMM (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, Annex 6, paragraphs 5.9 to 5.19) and the Scientific Committee (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, paragraph 5.8).

The workshop will also consider the report of the Workshop for the Development of a Dissostichus mawsoni Population Hypothesis for Area 48 (held in Berlin, Germany, 19 to 21 February 2018), focusing on specific outputs relating to the further development of the WSMPA proposal.

Documents

WG-SAM-18/33 Rev. 1	Annex to WS-DmPH-18 report: Towards the development of a stock hypothesis for Antarctic toothfish (Dissostichus mawsoni) in Area 48 M. Söffker, A. Riley, M. Belchier, K. Teschke, H. Pehlke, S. Somhlaba, J. Graham, T. Namba, C.D. van der Lingen, T. Okuda, C. Darby, O.T. Albert, O.A. Bergstad, P. Brtnik, J. Caccavo, A. Capurro, C. Dorey, L. Ghigliotti, S. Hain, C. Jones, S. Kasatkina, M. La Mesa, D. Marichev, E. Molloy, C. Papetti, L. Pshenichnov, K. Reid, M.M. Santos and D. Welsford
WS-DmPH-18/01	Materials on biodiversity in Subareas 48.6 and 48.5 in the frame of the Weddell Sea MPA Delegation of the Russian Federation
WS-DmPH-18/02	Оn seasonal and interannual dynamics of ice conditions in the Weddell Sea and its relation to the WSMPA planning Delegation of the Russian Federation
WS-SM-18/08	Informing and seeking advice from WS-SM 2018 about the revisions of the WSMPA proposal S. Hain, K. Teschke, H. Pehlke and T. Brey
WS-SM-18/09	Comments on the development of a Dissostichus mawsoni Population Hypothesis for Area 48. Proposals on the WS-SM-18 advice to the to the Scientific Committee and its Working Group Delegation of the Russian Federation
WS-SM-18/10	Comments on the use of MPA for spatial management in the CCAMLR area Delegation of the Russian Federation
WS-SM-18/11	Peculiarities of spatial-temporal variability of oceanological conditions in the Weddell Sea region in the context of the development of a stock hypothesis for Antarctic toothfish (Dissostichus mawsoni) in Area 48 V. Shnar and S. Kasatkina
WS-SM-18/13	Scientific background document in support of the development of a CCAMLR MPA in the Weddell Sea (Antarctica) – Version 2018 – Reflection on the recommendations by WG-EMM-17 and SC-CAMLR-XXXVI K. Teschke, H. Pehlke and T. Brey

0.237

3.3 Planning Domains 5 and 6 (Del Cano–Crozet and Kerguelen Plateau)

Annotations

The workshop will review progress and updates on the development of a representative system of Indian Ocean sub-Antarctic MPAs, including work progressed by the Indian Ocean sub-Antarctic spatial planning e-Group (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, Annex 6, paragraphs 3.29 to 3.37).

Documents

WS-SM-18/07

Predator trophic hotspots in the Indian sector of the subantarctic Southern Ocean: how do they overlap with marine protected areas?
M. O’Toole, S. Sergi, A. Baudena, C. Cotté, C. Bost, C. Guinet, H. Weimerskirch, M.A. Hindell, P. Koubbi and F. d’Ovidio

0.033

4 Research and monitoring plans

Documents

0.013

4.1 General principles for MPA research and monitoring

Annotations

The workshop will consider general principles and common approaches for efficient and effective monitoring and assessment of MPAs, including through MPA research and monitoring plans.

Documents

WS-SM-18/04	Developing the risk assessment framework for the Antarctic krill fishery in Area 48 P. Trathan, V. Warwick-Evans, E. Young, S. Thorpe, E. Murphy, N. Kelly, S. Kawaguchi and D. Welsford
WS-SM-18/05	An experimental approach for the Antarctic krill fishery: advancing management and conservation through the use of Krill Reference Areas and Krill Fishing Areas P.N Trathan and O.R. Godø
WS-SM-18/06	Hierarchical monitoring plans to determine patterns of change in the Antarctic Marine Ecosystem P. Trathan
WS-SM-18/10	Comments on the use of MPA for spatial management in the CCAMLR area Delegation of the Russian Federation
WS-SM-18/P01	Abundance and richness of key Antarctic seafloor fauna correlates with modelled food availability J. Jansen, N.A. Hill, P.K. Dunstan, J. McKinlay, M.D. Sumner, A.L. Post, M.P. Eléaume, L.K. Armand, J.P. Warncock, B.K. Galton-Fenzi and C.R. Johnson
WS-SM-18/P02	Model-based mapping of assemblages for ecology and conservation management: A case study of demersal fish on the Kerguelen Plateau N.A. Hill, S.D. Foster, G. Duhamel, D. Welsford, P. Koubbi and C.R. Johnson

0.05

4.2 Development of specific MPA Research and Monitoring Plans

Annotations

The workshop will continue the development of the Ross Sea region MPA research and monitoring plan (addressing Scientific Committee comments, SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, paragraph 5.45), and discuss mechanisms for its implementation. It will consider the development of baseline data, criteria and indicators for the RSRMPA (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI/20, paragraphs 21 to 25; and SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, paragraph 5.45) and the development of the RSRMPA project lists (SC-CAMLR-XXXVI/20, paragraphs 10 and 11; and SC-CAMLR-XXXVI, paragraphs 5.44 and 5.45).

The workshop will also consider updates to the draft South Orkney Islands southern shelf MPA research and monitoring plan, in advance of the review of this MPA in 2019.

Documents

WS-SM-18/01	Baseline data layers used for spatial planning, monitoring and research in relation to the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area M. Pinkerton and B. Sharp
WS-SM-18/02	Candidate baseline data for ecosystem indicators in the Ross Sea region A. Dahood and G.M. Watters
WS-SM-18/03	Summary of New Zealand research projects relevant to the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area M. Pinkerton and J. Scarrow
WS-SM-18/15	Research and Monitoring Plan for the South Orkney Islands Southern Shelf Marine Protected Area (MPA Planning Domain 1, Subarea 48.2) P.N. Trathan and S. Grant
WS-SM-18/16	Proposed initiative to contribute to Ross Sea region MPA research and monitoring activities using pop-up satellite tags and otolith chemistry on Dissostichus mawsoni C.D. Jones

0.133

5 Spatial planning data management

Annotations

The workshop will develop recommendations for data management in relation to:

Spatial management planning processes
MPA research and monitoring plans.

This will include consideration of the requirements for data management by the Secretariat (noting ongoing work by the Data Management Group), as well as the potential links with, and use of, existing external data portals and warehouses (e.g. SOOS).

Specifically in relation to the RSRMPA, this will include a preliminary discussion on how the Scientific Committee should review Member reports on scientific activities in 2021 as specified under CM 91-05 (paragraph 15), and how the Secretariat should compile such reports.

Documents

0.006

6 Future work

Documents

WS-SM-18/09

Comments on the development of a Dissostichus mawsoni Population Hypothesis for Area 48. Proposals on the WS-SM-18 advice to the to the Scientific Committee and its Working Group
Delegation of the Russian Federation

0.014

6.1 Priority research topics to inform future work on spatial management

Annotations

The workshop will identify prioritised research topics within the theme of ‘Spatial management of impacts on the Antarctic ecosystem’ to provide to the Scientific Committee for consideration in updating its five-year work plan.

Documents

0.009

6.2 Cooperation with other scientific programs

Annotations

The workshop will consider the scope and potential mechanisms for future cooperation and collaboration with other scientific programs (e.g. SCAR, SOOS, ICED), in terms of the provision of data relating to the development of spatial management and MPA research and monitoring.

Documents

0.007

6.3 Future organisation of spatial management work by the Scientific Committee and its working groups

Annotations

The workshop will discuss how future SC-CAMLR work on the scientific and data aspects of spatial management can most effectively be undertaken given existing working group structures and agendas.

Documents

WG-SAM-18/21

Guidelines for fisheries-directed research addressing the Ross Sea region Marine Protected Area Research and Monitoring Plan
S. Parker and A. Dunn

0.05

7 Other business

Annotations

Participants are invited to identify issues for consideration under Other business. Papers submitted under this agenda item should link their content to the workshop terms of reference and identify specific actions sought.

Documents

0.007

8 Advice to the Scientific Committee

Annotations

The Workshop will provide advice to the Scientific Committee and to other working groups as appropriate. Specific advice will be summarised in this agenda item following general discussion in other agenda items.

Documents

WS-SM-18/09

0.017

9 Adoption of report and close of meeting

Annotations

As is usual practice in meetings of the Scientific Committee and its working groups, rapporteurs will draft sections of the report according to general guidelines for its production. The Secretariat is responsible for formatting, editing and circulation of the report. Any proposed changes to the report prior to report adoption should be arranged through the rapporteurs or the Co-conveners using the web-based document management system. Adoption of the report will be conducted interactively.

Discussion will conclude by midday on Thursday, allowing Thursday afternoon and evening for report preparation and reading. Report adoption will be on Friday morning.

Documents

0.017

0.002